H. H. Holmes Murder Castle Site

In 1895, Chicago police dug human bones out of the cellar of H. H. Holmes’ building on this Englewood corner, which the papers called his “castle.” A post office stands here now, and its basement is said to be haunted.

History

The Corner Lot

When Herman Webster Mudgett came to Chicago in the 1880s, calling himself H. H. Holmes, he took over a drugstore on the northwest corner of Wallace Avenue and 63rd Street, in Englewood, on the city’s South Side. Then he bought the empty lot across the street and put up a building of his own: storefronts on the ground floor, a new drugstore among them, and apartments upstairs. Wikipedia dates the start of construction to 1887. CBS Chicago, drawing on the work of Adam Selzer, a Chicago author who wrote a book on Holmes in 2017, has it built between 1889 and 1891.

In 1892, Holmes added a third floor and told people it would be a hotel. It “was never finished or furnished or open to the public,” Selzer told History.com. The building did have secret rooms and passages, he says, “but the city knew all about them before the World’s Fair even opened.”

In July 1895, with Holmes in jail in Philadelphia and a detective there digging up the bodies of two of his business partner’s children in Toronto, the Chicago police went through the building. By then the papers were calling it Holmes’ “castle.” On July 25, the Rock Island Argus reported that they had found part of a human skeleton in the cellar, “believed that of little Pearl Conner,” and a second bed of quicklime with a human bone in it.

They kept going. “Human blood was found yesterday in Holmes’ ‘Castle’ bespattered from one room to another,” the Argus reported on August 6. A rope found in a dark chamber had blood in its knots. In the rooms of Pat Quinlan, the building’s janitor, were two trunks bearing the initials of Minnie R. Williams. The police got “a partial confession” from Quinlan, and a Vermont paper reported that “the indications are that in the graves were laid the bodies of Minnie and Annie Williams.” Emeline Cigrand, another young woman, was “said to have been murdered by H. H. Holmes,” a Montana paper wrote that August, in a story about her father, Peter.

The Fire

On August 19, 1895, the castle caught fire. Afterward, the fire marshal found “a can half filled with gasoline underneath the secret stairway on the second floor,” the Scranton Tribune reported, and he was convinced the fire had been set. Nobody was charged in what we’ve read. The building survived, and stayed in use until it was torn down in 1938. The Englewood post office was built on the lot.

Hauntings & Lore

The Murder Castle

The castle grew in the telling almost at once. On August 11, 1895, Joseph Pulitzer’s New York World printed a floor plan of it with a vault, a crematory and a trapdoor, which Wikipedia calls fictional. The papers called it “the Holmes Castle” then, Selzer writes, and only “decades later, ‘The Murder Castle.’” By 1943, the writer John Bartlow Martin could tell Harper’s readers that it had been “fitted with operating tables, a crematory, pits containing quicklime and acids,” a hotel “ostensibly” built for visitors to the World’s Fair.

The record is smaller and, in its way, worse. “The castle never for one day truly functioned as a hotel,” Selzer writes, “and the actual number of World’s Fair tourists he’s suspected of killing there has remained the same since 1895—a single woman, Nannie Williams.” The figure of 200 victims began, he says, with “kind of a throwaway line” in a 1940 book.

The Basement

The castle’s cellar is gone, but the post office has a basement, and that’s where the stories are now. “Many people say the basement of the Post Office that now occupies the Murder Castle site can be very creepy,” Tony Szabelski of Chicago Hauntings, a ghost tour company, told CBS Chicago. “They report hearing sounds or seeing shadow figures.”

Jeff Mudgett, a descendant of Holmes, went down there. Post office employees had warned him off, by the account of the tour company American Ghost Walks: “Don’t go down there. It’s a terrible, haunted place.” “Before I walked down those steps I was a non believer,” he says. “An hour later, when I came out, my whole foundation had changed. I was a believer.”

The corner is a stop on the ghost tours listed under Tours That Stop Here, and the post office is open to anyone with mail to send.

Visit

Visiting H. H. Holmes Murder Castle Site

  • Official visitor info: none: the site is a working United States Postal Service post office.
  • How to visit: Open to the public: it’s a working post office. The castle itself is gone. Tours: ghost tours stop on the corner (see Tours That Stop Here).
  • Finding the story sites: The castle stood on the corner of 63rd Street and Wallace Avenue, where the post office is now.
  • Worth knowing: Nothing of the castle survives above ground. The building was torn down in 1938.

Location

611 W 63rd St, Chicago, IL 60621


Been here?

Tell us what happened.

Join to share your story


Contributors

Spookt Logo
Sources (9)

Chronicling America

loc.gov

The Library of Congress's newspaper archive: the Rock Island Argus, July 25 and August 3 and 6, 1895; the Windham County Reformer (Vermont), August 1895; the Great Falls Weekly Tribune, August 2, 1895; the Scranton Tribune, August 20, 1895.

The Holmes-Pitezel Case

Frank P. Geyer, Philadelphia, 1896 (Internet Archive)

The True History of H.H. Holmes

WTTW · Alexandra Silets, May 10, 2017

With an excerpt from Adam Selzer's *H. H. Holmes: The True History of the White City Devil*.

Is All That Stuff About H. H. Holmes True?

Time Out Chicago · Adam Selzer, 2015

The Master of the Murder Castle

Harper's · John Bartlow Martin, December 1943

H. H. Holmes

Wikipedia