Westin St. Francis

Actress Virginia Rappe fell fatally ill at silent-film star Fatty Arbuckle’s 1921 party in rooms 1219 to 1221, and Al Jolson died in the same suite in 1950. Ghost tours say the 12th floor holds three ghosts.

History

The St. Francis opened on Union Square in March 1904. The heirs of the railroad magnate Charles Crocker built it for $2.5 million, and 600 of the city’s most fashionable people spent its opening night sipping Moet & Chandon. Four months later, the hotel had its first death of note. Charles’s younger brother Henry had moved in with his wife and son as one of its first permanent residents. He died at the hotel after a short illness, aged 72.

The St. Francis came through the earthquake of April 18, 1906, well enough that the opera star Enrico Caruso was served breakfast there later that morning. Then the fire that followed gutted the hotel. It was five days before the building stopped smoldering enough for the wine cellar manager, James Hall, to learn what had become of his fox terrier, locked in the cellar when the fire came. The dog came out “unsinged, although nearly dead from thirst and hunger,” the San Francisco Chronicle reported, and it was renamed Francis, after the hotel. Three months after the fire, the Merchants’ Association held its annual dinner in the hotel’s charred banquet hall. Today, the rebuilt hotel is the Westin St. Francis.

Hauntings & Lore

The St. Francis’s ghost stories gather on the 12th floor, around a party held there on Labor Day 1921. KQED, the Bay Area’s public radio station, counts what happened that day as the most notorious thing to happen at the hotel.

Room 1219

Labor Day, 1921

Six years before the party, the St. Francis appeared in one of Roscoe “Fatty” Arbuckle’s own films. A scene in the 1915 short Mabel and Fatty Viewing the World’s Fair pans up the hotel’s front, and anyone who knows where to look can just make out the window of Room 1219. Mark Hull, a former prosecutor who teaches criminal law and history, points it out in his 2018 account of the case for the Bar Association of San Francisco’s magazine.

In 1921, Arbuckle was paid more than any other actor in Hollywood. On September 3, he drove up from Los Angeles with his friends Lowell Sherman and Fred Fishback. They checked into three connecting rooms on the 12th floor: 1219, 1220, and 1221. Prohibition was the law, but the men had brought alcohol with them, and Sherman bought more. In the early afternoon of Labor Day, September 5, an impromptu party of music, dancing, and drinking got going in the suite. Among the guests were Maude Delmont and Virginia Rappe, a model, fashion designer, and silent-film actress.

What happened to Rappe in Room 1219 has never been settled, and no two witnesses agreed on it. Arbuckle testified that he found her sick and disoriented in his bathroom and carried her to the bed. He said he called the women at the party for help, sent for the hotel physician, and arranged for Rappe to stay in another room. Some ghost stories say she died in the suite, but she died four days later at Wakefield’s Sanitarium on Sutter Street, of peritonitis caused by a torn bladder.

Three Trials

On September 9, the day Rappe died, Delmont went to the Hall of Justice to report a murder. The San Francisco Chronicle and William Randolph Hearst’s Examiner led the coverage, and the Examiner’s headline read “S.F. BOOZEFEST KILLS ACTRESS.” A grand jury indicted Arbuckle for manslaughter.

Delmont had a long criminal record for extortion and fraud. Two days before Rappe died, she had wired two acquaintances: “We have Roscoe Arbuckle in a hole here chance to make money out of him.” Prosecutors left her off the witness list at all three of Arbuckle’s trials. His first jury deadlocked with all but one juror for acquittal, and his second split nine to three for conviction. The third acquitted him and issued a written apology: “Acquittal is not enough for Roscoe Arbuckle. We feel that a great injustice has been done him.”

Arbuckle was blacklisted for years, and he died in 1933, just as his career was on the verge of a comeback. Hull writes that Arbuckle was “certainly innocent” of the charge. He also writes that in court, Arbuckle’s lawyers set about “deliberately trashing” Rappe’s private life.

Al Jolson’s Last Hand

Nearly 30 years after the party, the same suite saw another death. The singer Al Jolson, the star of the early talking picture The Jazz Singer, checked into the St. Francis on October 23, 1950. He had recently come back from entertaining troops in Korea. That night, he was playing gin rummy in his rooms with his arranger, Martin Fried, and the songwriter Harry Akst.

In KQED’s account, the game was in the parlor, Room 1220. Midway through it, Jolson complained of chest pains and put himself to bed in 1221. Minutes later, he called to his friends, “Boys, this is it.” His last words were “Well boys, I’m going.” The New York Times reported that he died just after 10:30 p.m.

The Ghosts of the 12th Floor

The Haunt Ghost Tours, a San Francisco ghost tour company, says the 12th floor is rumored to have three ghosts. One is Rappe. Many visitors, it says, report seeing her ghost “roaming the halls of the hotel, tearing her hair out.” Jolson, it says, is “often seen sitting at a card table, his attention completely fixated on the cards before him.”

The third is a woman who lived at the hotel for years and died peacefully in her sleep. The company calls her kind and jovial, and says “you have nothing to fear from her.” Other guests, it says, have woken in the middle of the night from horrible nightmares.

Lydia Sviatoslavsky, writing for the Bay Area news and nightlife site Broke-Ass Stuart in 2021, adds Arbuckle to the list: “Sightings of Arbuckle have also been reported.” She writes that Room 1219 “is said to be the most haunted room in the St. Francis Hotel,” though “the entirety of the twelfth floor is reportedly haunted.”

If you’d like to investigate, The Haunt recommends staying in rooms 1219 to 1221. If you’re after a good night’s sleep, it says, steer clear of the 12th floor.

Book a stay and ask for Room 1219, or any room on the 12th floor.

Visit

Visiting Westin St. Francis

Book a stay on Expedia

Ask for Room 1219, because it is said to be the most haunted room in the hotel.

  • How to visit: Open to the public: the lobby, shops, and restaurants welcome non-guests. Stay the night and ask for Room 1219 or another room on the 12th floor when you book, though a request isn’t a promise of a room.

Book through our links and Spookt gets a small cut, at no extra cost to you. It keeps the research going. How that works

Location

335 Powell St, San Francisco, CA 94102


Been here?

Tell us what happened.

Join to share your story

Contributors

Spookt Logo
Sources (6)

The Many Trials of Fatty Arbuckle

San Francisco Attorney Magazine (Bar Association of San Francisco) · Mark Hull, 2018

Al Jolson Dead After Korea Tour

New York Times, October 24, 1950

Al Jolson Dies: Oct. 23, 1950

Jolsonville, reprinting the New York Times report, 2012

The Dark & Disturbing History of the St. Francis Hotel

Broke-Ass Stuart · Lydia Sviatoslavsky, 2021